Intro
A few weeks ago, in the post USDT and USDC: two digital dollars, we described how only one digital dollar was, in practice, left on European exchanges. It was Circle’s USDC, compliant with the European MiCA regulation. A year ago, by contrast, we wondered whether MiCA itself was discouraging stablecoins, indirectly doing Trump a favor.
On Wednesday 12 November the story got a sequel worthy of a comedy. The first European stablecoin classified as “significant” by the European Banking Authority (EBA) is in US dollars. It is USDC itself, and since that day the EBA has directly supervised its reserves (EBA press release).
Europe wanted to defend the euro and finds itself supervising, first of all, a dollar. Irony of fate? Perhaps. Let’s see what changes and why the most cautious regulators remain uneasy.
Why the first European stablecoin is in dollars
On 14 October the EBA classified USDC as a significant e-money token (EMT): the first of the 45 notified in the Union (EBA). An EMT is a stablecoin linked to a single official currency. It becomes significant if it exceeds at least three MiCA thresholds, such as number of holders, value issued and transactions (MiCA, Articles 43 and 56).
Competition in euros, after all, is tiny: according to Christine Lagarde, almost 98% of stablecoins are in dollars (Lagarde’s speech). And Qivalis, the European banks’ stablecoin, had its license at the end of October but not yet its token.
What changes from 12 November (and what doesn’t)
USDC’s European issuer is Circle Internet Financial Europe SAS, a French company that until now answered only to the ACPR, the Paris banking supervisor. From 12 November, MiCA provides for dual supervision (MiCA, Article 117; EBA):
- the EBA takes over own funds, reserves, liquidity, and recovery and redemption plans;
- the ACPR keeps governance, shareholders, the fitness of managers, outsourcing and conflicts of interest.
The rules also become stricter. Own funds rise to 3% of the average reserve, which must be audited every six months by an independent auditor (MiCA, Articles 45 and 58).
And what about those who hold USDC in a wallet or on an exchange? In practice nothing changes, and there is nothing to do. Anyone in the European Economic Area can always ask Circle SAS to redeem it at par (Circle’s white paper). The usual limit remains: USDC is not a deposit and is not covered by the deposit guarantee (€100k).
USDC in dollars, but if things went wrong… Europeans would pay (in euros)
On paper, USDC has two issuers: Circle SAS in France and Circle Internet Financial, LLC in the United States (EBA). The funny part, though, is that there is only one token: according to Circle, USDC from the two issuers is “fully fungible” (white paper). On the blockchain, in practice, a “French” USDC and an “American” one are indistinguishable.
The reserves, however, are separate. Circle SAS must cover the USDC held in the European Economic Area, Circle LLC the rest of the world. If holders move toward Europe, the group rebalances the reserves between the two companies (white paper).
And what if, in a crisis, everyone rushed to redeem in Europe? Circle itself admits it: the American company might not transfer the reserves in time, and Circle SAS could then temporarily limit redemptions (white paper).
This is exactly what the European Systemic Risk Board (ESRB) fears: a run on the European issuer that drains its reserves (ESRB). The ESRB and central banks are calling for these schemes to be banned, or locked down with robust safeguards (ESCB). The Commission has closed its consultation on the MiCA review but has not yet decided (Commission). So, from 12 November, the EBA supervises reserves that cover only part of a global token.
Who would foot the bill in that case? Certainly not the dollar. The ones left queuing at the counter would be European USDC holders. But careful, under current rules nothing provides for public money to cover Circle, and USDC enjoys no state guarantee. Only those who hold it would lose out. The EBA’s supervision is meant precisely to prevent this, but the question remains open and the Commission will have to answer it.
For now, then, the first European stablecoin speaks American. But if things went wrong, the bill would arrive in euros.
This article is for information only and is not financial advice.

